The Reviewer

A small magazine about things that claim to work

Apparatus · The number that matters on the box

Air purifiers: how to read CADR and size one for the room you actually have

The box will tell you about filter stages, ions and 'up to' room sizes. The figure worth reading is the clean air delivery rate, and the U.S. EPA publishes a simple chart for matching it to your floor area.

What we looked at

Portable air cleaner with a HEPA filter and a published CADR

The combination the EPA describes for removing particles; size it by the CADR, not the marketing room size.

Recommended

Activated carbon filter

Useful for odours and some gases, but only with a substantial amount of carbon, and there is no widely used rating to compare them.

Recommended with reservations

Ozone generators sold as air cleaners

Ozone is a lung irritant; the EPA advises against using devices that produce it to clean indoor air.

Not recommended

Air purifier boxes are crowded with claims: five-stage filtration, “true HEPA”, ionisers, coverage “up to” some impressive number of square feet. Most of that is decoration. The number that tells you whether a portable unit can actually clean the air in your room is smaller and often tucked on the side of the box: the clean air delivery rate, or CADR.

What CADR measures

CADR is a measure of how much filtered air a unit delivers, in cubic feet per minute. It’s tested separately for smoke, dust and pollen, the three sizes of particle that cover most of what people buy a purifier for, so you’ll often see three figures. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s guide puts the principle plainly: the higher the CADR, the more particles the cleaner can filter and the larger the area it can serve.

That’s why it’s more useful than the room size on the box. “Up to 1,000 sq ft” can mean the unit will change that room’s air slowly, over a long time, rather than the several times an hour you’d want if smoke or pollen is the reason you bought it.

The EPA’s sizing chart

The EPA gives a simple chart for removing particles, assuming an 8-foot ceiling:

Room areaMinimum CADR
100 sq ft65 cfm
200 sq ft130 cfm
300 sq ft195 cfm
400 sq ft260 cfm
500 sq ft325 cfm
600 sq ft390 cfm

The pattern is easy to remember: the CADR should be roughly two-thirds of the floor area in square feet. A 12-by-15-foot bedroom is 180 square feet, so look for a smoke CADR of at least about 120. If your ceilings are higher than 8 feet, or the room opens onto others, go bigger.

For smoke, use the smoke figure. It’s usually the lowest of the three, and smoke particles are the smallest and the hardest to catch.

Speed, noise and the honest trade-off

The published CADR is measured at the unit’s highest setting. The EPA notes that higher fan speeds and longer run times filter more air, and that a cleaner set to a low speed filters less.

That’s the real catch with portable purifiers. Many people run them on the quietest setting overnight, which can be a fraction of the rated CADR. A purifier that is too small for the room is not a slower version of the right one. Running quietly in the corner, it may be barely doing anything at all. If noise matters, buy a unit rated comfortably above what the chart asks for, so a middle setting still does the job.

Gases and odours are a different problem

CADR covers particles only. For cooking smells, some volatile chemicals or smoke odour, you need an activated carbon filter, and the EPA says these can be effective only with a substantial amount of carbon. A thin carbon-dusted sheet in a cheap unit won’t do much. There’s no widely used rating to compare carbon filters, so this part of the box is mostly on trust.

Skip anything that produces ozone on purpose. Ozone is a lung irritant, and the EPA advises against using ozone generators to clean indoor air.

The running costs

Filters need replacing, and a clogged one works poorly. Before buying, look up the price and the recommended replacement interval of the unit’s filters. A cheap purifier with expensive, frequently changed filters can cost more over three years than a better unit.

What we’d actually do

Measure the room. Multiply the floor area by about two-thirds and look for a smoke CADR at least that high. Better still, buy a size up so you can run it at a quieter setting. Choose a HEPA-type particle filter, add carbon only if smells are the problem, ignore ionisers and anything that makes ozone, and price the replacement filters before you pay. If you have asthma or another lung condition, an air cleaner is a sensible addition, but it doesn’t replace the advice of whoever treats you.

On the record

Every figure above is ours, attributed to a named third party, or the maker's own claim. These are the attributed ones, with their sources.

Inés Okonkwo

Editor

Founded this because product writing had stopped distinguishing between a measurement and a press release. Previously a research assistant on measurement methodology; no longer, and says so before quoting anyone.

Elsewhere in the magazine